Ignition Coil Comparison, Primary Energy

ninjacoupe

Specialist
Apr 25, 2017
91
73
0
I heard you ran a 0.99 gap too or was that a 0.020? Wait, nobody knows what gap you ran yet as you haven't told us! ;)

Sorry I tried a lot of plug and gap combinations with the coils. I tried copper plugs, Brisk silver and even tried those hand built GT-R plugs from Japan, misfire city btw. I found that .021 using the go-nogo method is what worked best on the N20 plug for me above 30psi. If I was running 28psi I would open that up to .025 and even bigger below that boost.

IMG_0052.JPG IMG_0054.JPG IMG_0074.JPG IMG_0152.JPG
 
  • Like
Reactions: V8bait and fmorelli

Milan

Sergeant
Dec 24, 2016
413
241
0
jebi se
Ride
your mom
Bad choice for a comparison on the LS coils, assuming you used D585 coils. Those are commonly known to have problems at the dwell times you were testing them at. Try the other type of truck coil it's much better, I believe they are made by Metco. But even the standard LS 2/3/7/9 coils should do better in your test.
 

V8bait

Lieutenant
Nov 2, 2016
500
773
0
Texas
Bad choice for a comparison on the LS coils, assuming you used D585 coils. Those are commonly known to have problems at the dwell times you were testing them at. Try the other type of truck coil it's much better, I believe they are made by Metco. But even the standard LS 2/3/7/9 coils should do better in your test.

We tested the normal ones and they were less powerful. The issue you're talking about is when you dwell them too long and the smart coil triggers a protective spark, which is similar to advancing timing. This only happens at around 6ms, and yes it's a big problem... But only if you dwell them that long. Most LS builds will dwell them for around 4.5ms to avoid this. The 585 was the highest output LS tested.

In the .zip I posted there's some shots where we set the dwell to like 7ms and you can see the coil fire prematurely. Definitely shouldn't be called a "smart" coil lol.

Edit: @Milan here is a scope of the issue at long dwell on D858, purple is dwell signal, it's at ~7ms, you'll see the coil discharge on its own just before the signal ends. Big spark though.

7ms premature discharge failure 10x.PNG
 
Last edited:

Milan

Sergeant
Dec 24, 2016
413
241
0
jebi se
Ride
your mom
What coils did you use? The metco coils that look like a weird triangle will dwell to 6ms no problem. I have also never seen an issue with regular LS2 coils at that dwell but no reported whp gains either after extensive testing (in the LS community)
 
  • Like
Reactions: V8bait

V8bait

Lieutenant
Nov 2, 2016
500
773
0
Texas
What coils did you use? The metco coils that look like a weird triangle will dwell to 6ms no problem. I have also never seen an issue with regular LS2 coils at that dwell but no reported whp gains either after extensive testing (in the LS community)

Tested them straight from the dealer, and yes the LS2 dwelled there fine without issues but was about half as powerful. IIRC, the LS2 coil also saturated before the LS truck coil did, so running it out past like 4ms didn't have any advantage anyway. I did not test aftermarket coils as there's too much variation, some are better some are worse. The D858 was just a lot stronger than the LS2 coil at any dwell, that's why we used it for comparison. But I'll try to find one of the others you're talking about.
 
Last edited: